From Self-Doubt to Self-Insight: The Hidden Strengths Behind Imposter Syndrome
Penny Schlyer • July 1, 2025

Imposter Syndrome leads to spending your time proving rather than progressing

It’s natural. If you’ve ever stepped into a new role, taken on a major initiative, or made a bold move in your career, you’ve likely heard your little, yet powerful voice saying,


  • “Am I really ready for this?”


  • “Do I belong at this level?”


  • “What if they don’t respect me?”


  •  “What if they find out I’m not as capable as they think?”


This is imposter syndrome. And while it can feel like a sign of weakness or fraudulence, I challenge you to reconsider.

It’s actually something very different. It’s a signal that you’re growing.


The Leadership Truth: Doubt Is a Side Effect of Growth

Imposter syndrome doesn’t show up when you’re coasting. It shows up when you’re expanding, stepping beyond your comfort zone and into new levels of visibility, responsibility, and influence.


In fact, the further you rise, the more likely you are to encounter it. Why? Because leadership isn't about having all the answers, it's about navigating ambiguity with integrity. And that’s uncomfortable.


What if, instead of resisting imposter feelings, you took a step back and learned to decode them?


What’s Hiding Inside the Doubt?

At Authentic Impact Business Coaching, we coach leaders to identify the root belief behind the feeling of self-doubt, and then reframe by asking, “What strength is this doubt pointing to?”


What if your Imposter Thought was actually a Hidden Leadership Strength? Consider the following...


  • “I’m not qualified” = I have the humility and the drive to learn


  • “They’ll see through me” = I am committed to be authentic


  • “I don’t want to fail.” = I hold myself to high internal standards and accountability


  • “Others are better than me.” = I respect excellence in others and want to emulate it


  • “What if I succeed?” = I understand and respect the weight of leadership

 

These aren’t signs of weakness. They’re signs of conscience, character, and care; the very qualities great leaders are built on.


Reframing the Narrative: From Imposter to Insight

Think about Imposter Syndrome differently. What if it was never about being inadequate, but about being in transition?


Here are some mindset shifts:


From: “I don’t belong here.”

To: “I’m evolving into the person who does.”


From: “I’m not as capable as they think.”

To: “They’re seeing potential and I’m still learning and evolving.”


From: “I feel like an imposter.”

To: “I’m growing into new leadership territory.”


The discomfort you feel isn’t false, it’s feedback. It means your role is stretching you, and you’re right there to rise to the challenge.


Turning Insight Into Strength

The executive coaching we provide focuses on practical mindset and behavior alignment. When leaders feel imposter syndrome, we encourage five grounded steps:

  1. Name the Fear: Acknowledge what the doubt is actually about. Unspoken fear breeds anxiety, named fear invites clarity.

  2. Ground in Evidence: Look at your track record, recent results, and trusted feedback. Facts quiet fiction.

  3. Reframe the Story: Replace self-judgement with self-observation. Growth isn't about knowing, it's about learning and giving yourself groom to grow.

  4. Simplify the Pressure: Delegate where possible. Say no where necessary. Let go of trying to prove and instead focus on the impact you are making.

  5. Act in Alignment: Courage doesn't require certainty, just commitment. Take small actions to build the muscle of being outside your comfort zone and reflect on who you're becoming.

 

Final Thought: Leadership Isn’t the Absence of Doubt

The leaders who grow the most are rarely the ones who never doubt themselves. They’re the ones who learn from their doubt, lead through it, and use it to sharpen their self-awareness.


So the next time imposter syndrome shows up, don’t shut it down. Ask it what it’s trying to teach you. You might find that underneath the discomfort is a deeper version of the leader you’re becoming.


Think of a recent moment when you felt self-doubt. What strength or value might that doubt be pointing to?


Want to discuss how Executive Coaching can help your team? Book a complimentary coaching call to find out.

Accountability in workplace
By Penny Schlyer May 21, 2025
Your Team Doesn’t Lack Motivation - You Might Just Be Holding the Keys
By Penny Schlyer April 9, 2025
The best teams don’t avoid conflict; they use it to fuel growth.
Happy Employees
By Penny Schlyer February 14, 2025
Your Rallying Cry isn’t just a mission statement—it’s the heartbeat of your business. It’s what excites you and your team to show up every day. It’s the deeper purpose behind why your company exists and the impact you want to create.
Business Coaching
By Penny Schlyer December 18, 2024
As a business owner, it’s good practice to take the time to assess whether your work reflects your purpose and passion so you can make some changes or double down full speed ahead. Reflecting on how your business is doing and what lies ahead can give you clarity.
By Penny Schlyer October 21, 2024
Hiring in today’s job market is more challenging than ever. Business owners are feeling the pressure to find candidates who not only have the skills to do the job but also care about the customer experience. If you’ve been frustrated by hiring employees who seem great in interviews but don’t deliver once on the job, you’re not alone. The workforce has changed, and many business owners are noticing a shift in work ethic post-COVID. But there’s still hope. You can attract the right candidates who genuinely care about making an impact by leveraging your unique customer experience as a hiring tool. Here’s how to craft job postings that attract employees aligned with your vision. 1. Focus on Impact, Not Just Tasks Most job descriptions are filled with lists of tasks and qualifications. But if you want to hire employees who care about more than just completing tasks, you need to focus on the impact they’ll have on your customer experience. Think about it this way: Instead of just saying, “Handle customer inquiries,” shift the focus to what that role contributes to your business. For example, “As part of our team, you’ll play a critical role in creating memorable experiences for our customers by ensuring every inquiry is handled with empathy and professionalism.” Why this works: People want to feel like they are part of something bigger than themselves. When you emphasize how their work impacts the overall customer experience, you attract candidates who are motivated by making a difference. 2. Steer Clear of Trendy Job Titles Writing fun, trendy job titles like “Customer Service Rockstar” or “Project Management Ninja” might be tempting, but these terms can sometimes backfire. While they sound playful, they don’t always communicate the seriousness of the role or the impact you expect employees to make. More importantly, these terms can attract the wrong candidates. If you do use this type of language, make sure to define what it actually means for your business. For example, if you’re using “Customer Service Rockstar,” you need to clarify that this means someone who excels at creating positive customer interactions and is committed to going above and beyond for each client. Why this matters: You want to attract candidates who understand the importance of the job and how it ties into your customer experience vision, not just those looking for a fun, trendy workplace. 3. Emphasize Your Values and Company Culture One of the biggest mistakes companies make when hiring is failing to communicate their unique values and culture. If your business prides itself on providing excellent customer service, your job posting should reflect that. Example: “We believe in going above and beyond for our customers. As a part of our team, you’ll contribute to delivering exceptional service, ensuring every interaction leaves a lasting, positive impression.” Why this is essential: In today’s market, employees aren’t just looking for a paycheck—they’re looking for structure, purpose, and the opportunity to make an impact. By emphasizing your company values and how employees contribute to your customer experience, you’ll attract candidates who want to be part of a well-respected team that shares their commitment to excellence. 4. Clarify the Role’s Contribution to Your Business’s Success When writing a job posting, it’s essential to communicate how the role contributes to the overall success of your business. Employees who understand their part in the bigger picture are likelier to take ownership of their role and deliver outstanding results. Ask yourself: How does this role fit into your business’s long-term strategy? How does it support the customer experience you’ve worked so hard to create? By answering these questions, you’ll craft a job description that resonates with candidates who are driven by more than just a paycheck. 5. Balance Qualities with Skills and Be Transparent About Challenges While it’s important to highlight the values and impact of the role, don’t forget to include the specific qualities and skills someone needs to succeed in the position. At the same time, be transparent about any challenges the role may involve, rather than glossing over them or using vague language. Think about it this way: For example, instead of saying: “We’re looking for a go-getter who’s willing to go above and beyond for our clients” —which might come off as a red flag to some solid candidates—you could say: “We’re looking for a candidate who prioritizes the customer experience, which may require working some nights and weekends.” Why this matters: Being upfront about the challenges helps you attract candidates who are truly ready to handle the demands of the role. Transparency builds trust with potential employees and ensures you’re bringing in people who understand what’s expected from the start. Attract Employees Who Care About Making an Impact Hiring employees who care about delivering exceptional customer experiences starts with how you position your roles. By focusing on the impact they’ll have, steering clear of confusing job titles, and emphasizing your company’s values and culture, you’ll attract candidates who align with your customer experience vision. Remember, the goal isn’t to fill a role—it’s to build a team that supports your business and delivers the customer experience you’ve worked so hard to create. Creating a culture of accountability in your business goes beyond one job posting, however. Need help defining the uniqueness of your customer experience and the culture you’re looking to create? Let’s schedule a consultation to talk about how you can attract and retain the right employees who are as passionate about your customers as you are.
Subconscious Mind
By Penny Schlyer July 11, 2024
Change your thinking. Focus on the solution instead.
By Penny Schlyer July 3, 2024
Have you considered the transformative power of picturing your endgame? Download this valuable eBook to learn about creating a roadmap for the next stage of your entrepreneurial journey.
Mow your lawn
By Penny Schlyer July 3, 2024
How you mow your lawn can say a lot about your behavior tendencies. Let's take a humorous look at DISC. During one of my coaching sessions last week, my client came up with a fun analogy about DISC profiles and mowing the lawn that I just had to share with you.
Creator
By Penny Schlyer February 12, 2024
In our businesses, careers, and life, it's easy to get distracted or derailed by circumstances that are seemingly beyond our control - hurdles standing in the way of our goals and dreams. But here's the thing: you can break free from this cycle and turn your constraints into opportunities!
Running Your Business
By Penny Schlyer December 13, 2023
Entrepreneurship can be an emotional roller coaster – from exhilarating highs when you win that big hairy contract, to gut-wrenching lows when the inevitable pitfalls of business hit hard. If you’re like most owners, you started your business, or took over the family business to follow a passion and to have freedom.
Show More